1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Access Point ONLY! WAP54G or WRT54G better for WLAN only?

Discussion in 'Other Linksys Equipment' started by junky, Jan 22, 2005.

  1. junky

    junky Network Guru Member

    Because of using a LANCOM DSL/10 Firewall/Router, which is very good and secure I really only need an Access Point! I do not need any WAN ports!

    But because of reading a little bit in this forum I thing about better buying a WRT54G Router than the WAP54G Access Point only.

    I read about the better hardware of the WRT model! Is that right? Should i buy the router, even when I do not need it?

    Amazon Germany sells the WRT54G for 64€ and the WAP54G for 55€, so the price istn't that important!

    The only thing I want to know is, what the WRT54G is doing better on the WLAN site, because the WAN ports I will never use. Could I use the WRT54G only in Access Point mode?

    Interesting also would be TX/RX monitoring and managing of the connected WLAN clients! Is that possible on one of the two machines with modified firmware?

    Thanks for answering!
  2. GiSWiG

    GiSWiG Network Guru Member

    I would say so, but I haven't done it myself. There are posts on Linksys's site about using the WRT54G/S behind another router, so look there. If ya don't use the Internet port, it is just basicly a switch for both wireless and wired. I do that with the BEFSR41 (older, wired only router)

    I would go with the router because there is more that you can do with it. If your interested in using things like OpenWRT, definately. I'm currently looking into using OpenWRT on my WAP for Static DHCP and for Kai Xlink, but I have come to some possible problems with that. The WAPs carry less memory to use for OpenWRT, and apparently the newer ones have less that the older ones (Ver 2 vs ver 1.) I belive I read that it would have a 2mb flash. Some posts I saw that showed the free space available once they got OpenWRT on it was ZERO! The WRT54G has 4mb flash w/ 16mb ram and the WRT54GS doubles that with 8 and 32.

    But if you find that you do not want to do anything like this, and it's cheaper than a router, then go for it. A local Staples (I live in the US) sells the WAP for more than the WRT54G and only $10 less than the WRT54GS at regular price, but they are on sale this week w/ rebates.

Share This Page