Is this an issue for anyone else with 3 or more routers using WDS-WPA/AES?

Discussion in 'Tomato Firmware' started by VVarwick, Jan 30, 2009.

  1. VVarwick

    VVarwick Addicted to LI Member

    This will be kind of hard to discribe but here it goes:

    I'm setting up 2 different wireless networks with 3 WRT54GL routers on each network. Both of them are set up in a daisy chain like below:

    Code:
    Network #1
    Internet----(router 1 GW)-------(router 2)-------(router 3)
    
    network #2
    (router 1)-------(router 2 GW)-------(router 3)
                              |
                              |
                         internet
    I'm using WDS-WPA/AES to connect the routers. I'm using Tomato 1.23 on network #2 and Tomato RAF 1.23.8510ND on network #1. Both exhibit the issue I'm about to describe.

    If all 3 routers are up and running, connected with WDS-WPA/EAS and can see each other but have no network traffic flowing between them, if I reboot router 2 and wait a few minutes before trying to send data over the network, WDS-WPA/AES will not reconnect between any of the routers. I have to reboot routers 1 and 3 and then all is well again.

    If all 3 routers are up and running, connected with WDS-WPA/AES and can see each other but have network traffic flowing (as in I have a continuous ping from a PC on router 1 pinging router 2 and a PC on router 3 pinging router 2) and I reboot router 2, WDS-WPA/AES will come right back up everytime WITHOUT having to reboot routers 1 and 3.

    I can recreate this issue pretty much every time by rebooting router #2 while no traffic is flowing on the network.

    I have found a "duct tape" patch that resolves the issue. If I turn on Spanning Tree Protocol on all 3 routers, I can reboot router #2 with no network traffic on my network and WDS-WPA/AES will reconnect every time.

    Spanning Tree Protocol should not be needed for a daisey chain WDS connection, but it is the only thing that makes my WDS-WPA/AES work 100% when rebooting any of the routers.

    Does anyone else have this issue? is this a known bug?

    thanks for any info!


    VVarwick
     
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice