I've tried everything, so to make things as clear as possible. I'm providing as many screen captures of my Windows Setup and my Tomato screen. I'm just trying to simply forward ports, it started off with trying to forward my Utorrent port, but in fact I can't successfully forward any port, but let's start with uTorrent. I've never had an issue forwarding a port before, not with my stock Linksys Firmware. I'm using the latest version of Tomato Shibby I could find: tomato-E4200USB-NVRAM60K-1.28.RT-MIPSR2-112-AIO I also read that when people have this problem they go the Administration Menu and reset their NVRAM, I did that by selecting "Restore all data in NVRAM memory (thorough)" but not difference. Here are my screens, I'm trying to forward port 17094. I connect wirelessly and from Tomato, I use the mac address to set a static IP of 192.168.1.44 to that wireless connection. I also tried using a LAN connection without wireless and setting a static IP from the network config of Windows, but it made no difference. In order to eliminate it being something related to Windows, I've turned off Windows Firewall and that made no difference, and it made no difference if I tried other ports. Can someone please show me what I'm doing wrong. Or maybe something is wrong with the latest Shibby? but then I would think I would see more people reporting that issue for such a popular firmware. Only thing worth adding is that I'm also using the openVPN client functionality, but right now even that is set to off.